The True Spirit of Crafting: The Difference Between Handmade and Mass-Produced Imitations
The True Spirit of Crafting: The Difference Between Handmade and Mass-Produced Imitations
We live in a world where convenience and affordability often trump quality and authenticity. As consumers, we’re constantly bombarded with “handmade” goods from mass-market websites that sell items at prices so low it’s almost too good to be true. These products—often made overseas in factories—are bought in bulk, slapped with a “handmade” label, and then passed off as someone’s personal craft. As a creator, this trend frustrates me deeply, not just because it undercuts the value of genuine craftsmanship but because it misrepresents what true handmade is all about.
The idea of “handmade” should evoke images of personal care, attention to detail, and creativity. It’s about crafting something unique with your own two hands—something that carries a piece of your story and effort. Unfortunately, in today’s world, this concept is being diluted by sellers who simply purchase mass-produced items from sites abroad, slap on a label, and call it their own. It’s not craft; it’s just assembly. It’s no longer about creating something from the heart—it’s about selling a cheap product for a profit, with no soul behind it.
Mass Production Poses as Crafting
This issue has become increasingly common, especially with the rise of online marketplaces that offer cheap wholesale products. Sellers purchase pre-made items, often made in factories overseas, and then repackage them with a handmade label. Some even make slight alterations to these mass-produced items, like adding a small decorative touch, and claim them as their “own work.” This isn’t crafting. It’s exploitation of the term "handmade" to capitalise on unsuspecting buyers.
For example, I’ve seen "handmade" jewellery being sold at prices that are far too low to be genuine, where the pieces are clearly bought in bulk from a supplier. The only change? Maybe a little bead added or a clasp replaced. The product is not made by the hands of a creator—it’s just mass-produced and packaged. As someone who pours hours of time and energy into creating every recycled paper bead in my jewellery, this can be disheartening. It undercuts everything that true crafters stand for: quality, passion, and originality.
The True Crafting Process: What It Really Takes
When I sit down to create, I am mindfully involved in every step of the process. For my recycled paper jewellery, I begin by gathering old flyers and magazines, carefully cutting them into strips, and then slowly rolling each piece into individual beads. Each bead takes time—sometimes hours—because it’s not just about making something to sell. It’s about creating something meaningful, made with intention. It’s not just a bead; it’s the story behind the paper I use and the care I put into every roll. The same goes for my Mood Collection—each item, from the soy wax melts to the mood sprays, is crafted with quality ingredients and thoughtfully designed. There’s a true sense of pride in knowing that what I’ve made isn’t just a product; it’s a reflection of my creativity and passion.
Crafting is an art form, and true craftsmanship isn’t just about assembling parts. It’s about learning, experimenting, and putting a part of your soul into every item you make. I’ve spent countless hours testing, refining, and perfecting the designs of my products—whether that’s getting the right scent blend for a wax melt or making sure the colours in my jewellery complement each other perfectly. That’s the heart of what I do.
Why Mass-Produced “Handmade” is Harmful to the Crafting Community
The proliferation of mass-produced goods being labelled as handmade hurts more than just the true crafters. It hurts the entire crafting community. When products are sold as “handmade” but are anything but, it undermines the value of true craftsmanship and misleads customers into thinking they’re buying something personal and unique, when in reality, it’s just another factory-made product. It also creates an unfair market for true makers like myself who are working hard to create something with integrity, love, and skill.
It’s difficult to compete when customers are drawn to these cheap, mass-produced items without realising the difference between genuine craft and assembly. I’ve had customers tell me that they can find similar products for much cheaper online, not realising that those “handmade” pieces aren’t crafted with care at all. They’re just cheap knockoffs, and unfortunately, the market is flooded with them.
This practice also promotes unsustainable consumerism, as these mass-produced goods are often made with cheap materials and poor labour practices. True crafters like myself are often committed to ethical sourcing, using sustainable materials (like my recycled paper jewellery), and taking the time to create products that will last. Mass-produced goods are made to be disposable, which directly contradicts everything I believe in as a maker.
Supporting True Craftsmanship: Why It Matters
When you buy from a true crafter, you’re not just buying a product—you’re supporting creativity, sustainability, and integrity. Each piece that comes from a true maker has a story, a journey, and a heart behind it. It’s made by someone who cares deeply about what they create and who invests their time, their soul, into their work. It’s personal, and it’s crafted with love.
As a crafter, I encourage people to ask questions and look beyond the label of "handmade." True craftsmanship is about quality over quantity. It’s about investing time into the process and valuing the product for what it is: a unique, one-of-a-kind item made with skill and dedication. Whether you’re purchasing a piece of recycled paper jewellery or a mood spray from my collection, you’re getting something that’s been thoughtfully created and carefully made, not just something slapped together at the last minute.
The Bottom Line: Let’s Celebrate Real Craftsmanship
I believe in the power of true handmade goods. The heart that goes into each item, the time it takes, and the love that surrounds every piece of work are what make crafting special. When you buy from a real crafter, you’re not just supporting a business—you’re supporting an artist, a creator, and a community of people who value the authenticity and soul behind every piece. So, the next time you’re looking for something unique and special, remember that true craft can’t be bought—it has to be made, with love, from the heart.
Follow My Journey
I’ll be posting updates on my essential oil studies, product-making process, and craft fairs over on TikTok & Instagram (@BlakesMakes)—follow along for behind-the-scenes insights!
https://www.facebook.com/blakesmakes1308
https://www.tiktok.com/@blakesmakes
